Chris Smith’s Five and the Forgotten Treasure is a delightful adventure that brings fresh excitement to both new readers and a little nostalgia for older readers that might have them returing to the Enid Blyton originals. This latest installment follows a new quintet on a treasure hunt that’s full of twists, turns, and unexpected surprises.
For newcomers, Smith’s engaging writing style and fast-paced plot make it a fun and easy read. The characters are vividly drawn, and the setting of Kirrin is rich with details that transport readers into the heart of the adventure. The narrative is laced with humor, mystery, and a sense of wonder that will surely capture the imaginations of young readers and those young at heart.
However, the book also tries hard to cater to historic fans of the series, which can sometimes feel a bit forced. If like me you grew up wiht the famous five you may find that the frequent nods to past adventures and overly nostalgic elements take away from the freshness of the story. While the intention to honor the series’ legacy is clear, it occasionally bogs down the narrative with a sense of déjà vu. On a personal level I struggled with the dogs name. Gilbert. Who calls their dig Gilbert? I might be biased having grown up loving ‘Timmy’ but really? Gilbert!
Despite these minor drawbacks, Five and the Forgotten Treasure remains an enjoyable read, and is likely a good book to get the younger audience interested in reading. The thrill of the chase and the camaraderie of the characters will undoubtedly leave readers eagerly turning pages. It’s a commendable addition to the series that manages to introduce new life while paying homage to its roots—just perhaps trying a bit too hard to please everyone.
One More Chapter 